Government Thinks in Contracts. Business Owners Think in Lifetimes.

Government Thinks in Contracts. Business Owners Think in Lifetimes.

Colourful murals displayed along the exterior of a grocery and retail store in Inuvik, Northwest Territories, Canada.

A northern business owner can spend thirty years building a company and still discover that government has given too little thought to what makes it worth buying.

From our perspective, too much government thinking about business ends at the next contract. Who gets the work? Where does the money go? How much stays locally?

Those are necessary questions. They are also incomplete.

Business Value Beyond the Next Contract

An owner is building a company that must eventually survive beyond them: dependable earnings, capable employees and customer relationships that continue when someone else takes over. Its value may finance retirement, support a family or fund another investment in the community.

Winning work contributes to that value. It does not automatically establish it.

A company can remain busy while becoming more dependent on one purchaser. It can increase revenue without improving profitability. Its founder can work harder every year without building an operation that somebody else could successfully run.

Another contract awarded locally tells us where work went. It tells us much less about the lasting wealth being built.

When Procurement Advantages Become Liabilities

Purchasing advantages tied to ownership illustrate how an immediate benefit can carry a future cost.

Consider a hypothetical contractor that qualifies for a procurement preference. The advantage helps its owner compete. Years later, a qualified buyer wants to acquire the company, retain its employees and continue operating locally.

But the ownership change would mean losing that advantage.

The equipment, employees and quality of service remain the same. The company’s commercial prospects have weakened. The buyer may offer less or walk away.

What helped the owner win work can become a liability when they try to sell.

That outcome is not inevitable. Preferences can increase earnings and help build valuable companies. The point is that their consequences extend beyond the next award. Those consequences deserve attention before an owner reaches retirement.

In a small market, every realistic investor and buyer matters. Decisions that narrow those options can affect a company long after the original contract has been completed.

Building Businesses That Outlast Their Founders

We believe government needs a longer view of northern enterprise. Its decisions should account for whether companies become more profitable, develop management beyond their founders and attract investment or successors. Conditions that help an owner today should also be examined for what happens when that owner leaves.

Keeping businesses working is a worthwhile objective. Building businesses that retain value through a change in ownership is another—and it deserves a place in government’s thinking.

A northern entrepreneur should not reach retirement and discover that government helped keep the company busy while making it harder to sell.

Recent Editorials

The NWT Has the Data. What It Lacks Is a Scoreboard.
Editorials

The NWT Has the Data. What It Lacks Is a Scoreboard.

The NWT measures spending, contracts and economic activity in considerable detail. What it does not measure nearly as consistently is whether all of that intervention is producing a stronger private …

SEED Can Start Businesses. Can It Grow Them?
Editorials

SEED Can Start Businesses. Can It Grow Them?

The Northwest Territories has programs that can help people start businesses. What is much less clear is whether those programs are designed to help successful businesses become substantially larger.

Did We Fund Another Idea, or Build Another Company?
Editorials

Did We Fund Another Idea, or Build Another Company?

Northern economic development has become very good at funding ideas. The harder question is whether those investments are actually producing durable companies.

Arctic Business is brought to you by the Western Arctic Business Association (WABA)—a member-led organization that supports business growth across the region through partnerships, practical programming, and advocacy on the conditions Northern enterprises need to succeed.